4. Choosing without ordering

In the last lesson, we counted arrangements. Changing the order usually created a new possibility.

But sometimes order does not matter at all.

A team is not an arrangement

Suppose Alice, Ben, Charlie and Dom are available, and we want to choose two people for a team.

If we use the choices-in-stages idea, there are 4 choices for the first person and then 3 choices for the second:

4 × 3 = 12

But that cannot be the number of different teams. The choice Alice then Ben gives the same team as Ben then Alice.

Main idea
If changing the order does not create a new possibility, do not count it again

When we choose a group, the same group may appear several times if we count it as an arrangement. We need to correct for that overcounting.

Let us list the six different two-person teams:

AB
AC
AD
BC
BD
CD

Each team appeared twice in the count 4 × 3: once in each order. So we divide by 2:

(4 × 3) ÷ 2 = 6

Practice puzzle
Choose two from six

Six children are available for a two-person quiz team.

How many different teams are possible?
💡
Learning tipCount ordered choices first. How many times does each two-person team get counted?
Reveal answer

There are 6 choices for the first person and 5 for the second, so there are 30 ordered selections.

Each team appears twice, once in each order.

(6 × 5) ÷ 2 = 15

There are 15 different teams.

Choosing more than two

Now suppose we choose three people from six.

If order mattered, there would be:

6 × 5 × 4 = 120

But each group of three people can be arranged in

3! = 3 × 2 × 1 = 6

different orders. So every three-person group has been counted six times.

120 ÷ 6 = 20

Important rule
Arrange first, then divide by the orders that do not matter

To choose r objects from n different objects, we may count the ordered selections and then divide by r!, because each chosen group can be arranged in r! different ways.

Practice puzzle
A committee of three

Eight people are available. A committee of three is chosen, with no special roles.

How many different committees are possible?
💡
Learning tipFirst count 8 × 7 × 6. Then ask how many orders describe the same group of three.
Reveal answer

There are 8 × 7 × 6 ordered selections.

Each group of three appears 3! = 6 times.

(8 × 7 × 6) ÷ 6 = 56

There are 56 committees.

A useful shorthand

Choosing r objects from n objects happens so often that mathematicians give it a special notation.

We write “n choose r”, sometimes written as C(n,r).

C(n,r) = n! ÷ (r!(n-r)!)

For example:

C(6,3) = 6! ÷ (3!3!) = 20

The formula is useful, but the important idea is still the same: count the arrangements, then correct for the orders that do not matter.

Practice puzzle
Pizza toppings

A pizza shop has 7 possible toppings. You choose exactly 4 different toppings.

How many different four-topping pizzas are possible?
💡
Learning tipUse C(7,4), or count 7 × 6 × 5 × 4 and divide by 4!.
Reveal answer

C(7,4) = 35

There are 35 different pizzas.

Choosing what stays is the same as choosing what goes

Suppose five people are available and we choose three for a team.

Choosing the three people who are on the team automatically tells us which two people are not on the team.

So:

C(5,3) = C(5,2)

Main idea
Choosing r is equivalent to leaving out n − r

For any n and r, C(n,r) = C(n,n-r). Sometimes choosing the smaller group is much easier to calculate.

Practice puzzle
Eight from ten

Ten books are on a table. You choose eight of them.

How many different selections are possible?
💡
Learning tipInstead of choosing the eight books you take, choose the two books you leave behind.
Reveal answer

C(10,8) = C(10,2) = 45

There are 45 different selections.

Challenge
Choose a team and a captain

Seven people are available. You choose a team of three, and then choose one of those three people to be captain.

How many different team-and-captain outcomes are possible?
💡
Learning tipFirst choose the unordered team. Then there is a second stage: choose the captain from within that team.
Reveal answer

There are C(7,3) = 35 possible teams.

For each team there are 3 possible captains.

35 × 3 = 105

There are 105 outcomes.

What have we learned?

When order does not matter, arrangement counting usually counts each choice too many times.

  • Ask whether changing the order creates a new possibility.
  • If it does not, count the arrangements and divide by the number of irrelevant orders.
  • Choosing r objects from n objects is written C(n,r).
  • C(n,r) = C(n,n-r).

The key question is still: what exactly counts as a different outcome?

Next: Pascal’s triangle

The numbers C(n,r) form a remarkable pattern.

In the next lesson we will build that pattern row by row and discover why the same numbers appear in Pascal’s triangle.

Help us improve

What did you think?

Whether you explored this together or worked independently, we would love to hear from both parents and young learners. Tell us what you enjoyed, what was confusing, or what you would like to see next.

Share your feedback

The form is short and you do not need to give your name.

COUNTING & COMBINATORICS COURSE
Keep exploring
← Previous lesson
Back to Counting & Combinatorics
Next lesson →